Matthew Poole and continuators on Joshua 5:2

2 At that time the Lord said unto Joshua, Make thee sharp knives † , and circumcise again the children of Israel the second time .

As soon as ever they were come to Gilgal, which was on the tenth day; and so this might be executed the next, or the eleventh day, and that in the morning: on the thirteenth day they were sore of their wounds, and on the fourteenth day they recovered, and at the Even of that day kept the Passover.

Or, prepare, or make ready, as this word is sometimes used. As it was not necessary for those who had such Knives already to make others for that use; so it is not probable that such were commanded to do so, but only to make them sharp and fit for that work.

Called in Hebrew, Knives of Flints, not as if they were all necessarily to be made of Flints, but because such were commonly used, especially in those parts where there was but little Iron; and because such Knives were oft used in this work, as the Iewish Doctors note, and in such like works, as Heathen writers relate. Thus we call that an Ink-horn, which is made of Silver, because those Utensils are commonly made of Horn.

He calleth this a second Circumcision, not as if these same persons had been Circumcised once before, either by Ioshua, or by any other, for the contrary is affirmed below, v. 7. but with respect unto the body of the People, whereof one part had been Circumcised before, and the other at this time, which is called a second time, in relation to some former time wherein they were Circumcised, either, 1. in Egypt, when many of the people, who possibly for fear or favour of the Egyptians, had neglected this Duty, were by the command of Moses (who had been awakened by the remembrance of his own neglect and danger thereupon), Circumcised; which during the Ten Plagues, and the grievous confusion and consternation of the Egyptians, they might easily find opportunity to do. Or 2. at Sinai, when they received the Pass-over, Numb. 9. 5. which no uncircumcised person might do, Exod. 12. 48. and therefore it may not seem improbable, that all the Children born in that first year after their coming out of Egypt, and all they who peradventure might come out of Egypt in their uncircumcision, were now Circumcised. Obj. 1. All that came out of Egypt were Circumcised, v. 5. Ans. 1. This may be true, but he doth not say when and where they were Circumcised; nor doth he deny that this was done to some of them, either in time of the Plagues in Egypt, or at Sinai. 2. All is very oft used of the greatest part, as is confessed. Obj. 2. All the people that were born in the Wilderness were not Circumcised, v. 5. Ans. 1. Understand this also of the greatest part. 2. This is limited to them that were born by the way, as it is said there, and emphatically repeated, v. 7. i. e. in their Journeys and Travellings; which insinuates the reason why they were not Circumcised, because they were always uncertain of their stay in any place; and were constantly to be in readiness for a removal when God took up the Cloud: But this reason ceased at Sinai, where they knew they were to abide for a considerable time; and seeing they took that opportunity for the celebration of the Pass-over, it is likely they would improve it also to the Circumcision of their Children or others, which they ought to prize highly, and to embrace all occasions offered for it; which though the people might, it is not likely that Moses would neglect. Obj. 3. They are said to have remained uncircumcised Forty whole Years in the Wilderness, v. 6. Ans. i. e. for almost 40 years; as the same Phrase is used, Numb. 14. 33, 34. and 32. 13. when there was above one year of that number past and gone. Or 3. in Abraham, and so the sense may be, The first Circumcision conferred upon Abraham, and continued in his Posterity, hath been for many years neglected or omitted; and so that great and solemn pledg of my Covenant with you, is in a manner wholly lo[illegible: 1+ letters]t, and therefore it is but fit and necessary to have this long interrupted practice of Circumcision revived, and to have Abrahams Posterity circumcised a second time for the renewing of the Covenant between them and me again.

Marginal references: Exod. 4. [illegible: 1+ letters]; ‡ Or, [illegible: 1 word] of flints.